New York Yankees Draft History

_{All tables below are based on the amount of WAR each player produced during their first seven seasons in Major League Baseball. The WAR totals for each draft class include both Pitching and Hitting WAR, but excludes any player that did not sign with their drafting team. The total WAR also reflects the total value the drafted player provided, not just the value to his drafting team.}

_{^{*Data accurate through 2019 season.}}

Top Five Draft Classes

Year	Team	WAR
1990	New York Yankees	61.1
1981	New York Yankees	48.5
2006	New York Yankees	46.5
1979	New York Yankees	39.6
2005	New York Yankees	38.9

Bottom Five Draft Classes

Year	Team	WAR
1985	New York Yankees	-3.2
2007	New York Yankees	-1.6
2000	New York Yankees	-1.5
1999	New York Yankees	-1.4
1983	New York Yankees	-1.4

This list excludes any season past 2010, since those draft classes have a multitude of active players.

Top Five Draft Picks

Year Drafted	Round	Overall Pick	Name	WAR
1990	22	594	Andy Pettitte	30.3
1981	9	233	Fred McGriff	28.8
1979	19	493	Don Mattingly	28.2
1971	3	67	Ron Guidry	28.0
1992	1	6	Derek Jeter	27.3

List made from top five WAR values alone.

Five Biggest Busts

Year Drafted	Round	Overall Pick	Name	WAR
1991	1	1	Brien Taylor	No MLB Experience
1966	1	10	Jim Lyttle	0.6
1969	1	11	Charlie Spikes	0.3
1970	1	12	Dave Cheadle	-0.2
1974	1	12	Dennis Sherrill	0.0

List made from first round picks that produced less than 5.0 WAR in their first seven seasons and ordered by lowest overall pick.

Top Five Value Picks

Year Drafted	Round	Overall Pick	Name	WAR
1990	22	594	Andy Pettitte	30.3
1979	19	493	Don Mattingly	28.2
1995	20	562	Mike Lowell	17.3
1970	30	700	Doc Medich	17.1
1990	24	646	Jorge Posada	14.3

List made from top five WAR values where a player was drafted outside of the first ten rounds.

Top Five Unsigned Draft Picks

Year Drafted	Round	Overall Pick	Name	WAR
1970	3	60	Fred Lynn	30.7
1967	60	925	Steve Rogers	29.8
2008	1	28	Gerrit Cole	29.5
2005	6	199	Doug Fister	18.5
1998	1	43	Mark Prior	17.3

List made from top five WAR values where a player did not sign with the team.

Click here for code used to create this page.